Essay on oligarchy

This lack of knowledge and skills then becomes evidence to reinforce the original belief that they are inferior. But this is not what Aristotle means by "living well". In a democracy where the people have authority over the law, it is advantageous in deliberating and assemblies to arrange a fine for nonattendance of those they want to have adjudicate to ensure that they do adjudicate, while the popular sort pay for the poor.

Aristotle's Politics: Oligarchy and Democracy Essay

They supported the creation of a well-developed legal system and capable regulatory apparatus. In the midst of the railroad strikes, that summer ofit called a rally. The result of all this, says David Montgomery, historian of the Kensington Riots, was the fragmentation of the Philadelphia working class.

For it is peculiar to man as compared to the other animals that he alone has a perception of good and bad and just and unjust and other things of this sort; and partnership in these things is what makes a household and a city a8. It was prompted by the Rhode Island charter's rule that only owners of land could vote.

The present system has enabled capitalists to make laws in their own interests to the injury and oppression of the workers. Soon there were ten-hour laws in Pennsylvania and other states, but they provided that employers could have employees sign contracts for longer hours.

The rebellion disintegrated and Dorr again fled Rhode Island. Congress had not appropriated money for the army yet, but J. Although the founders of cities create them for the sake of more comfortable lives, cities are unique in making it possible for people to live well. The house painters of Brooklyn have taken steps to counteract the attempt of the bosses to reduce their wages.

In political history of modern time, opposition of oligarchy to aristocracy disappeared. Second, there is a high property qualification for holding public office and they themselves elect in filling vacancies. There was panic among the six hundred workers, mostly women, and many jumped to their deaths from upper-story windows.

Women and children ran screaming in all directions. White workers of the North were not enthusiastic about a war which seemed to be fought for the black slave, or for the capitalist, for anyone but them.

Democracy and oligarchy essay

It is not made once and for all, but must be made over and over again as we live our lives. Italians were imported into the bituminous coal area around Pittsburgh in to replace striking miners. The oligarchs assert that their greater wealth entitles them to greater power, which means that they alone should rule, while the democrats say that the fact that all are equally free entitles each citizen to an equal share of political power which, because most people are poor, means that in effect the poor rule.

This is not the same as that of a man, but as with a man nature intends her to achieve virtues of the kind that are available to her: They admitted into their ranks, broken down lawyers and politicians But the power elite cannot be understood as a mere reflection of economic elites; rather it is the alliance of economic, political, and military power.

They shot off gunpowder, in protest against new factory rules, which charged fines for coming late, forbade talking on the job, and required church attendance. Third, they should have virtue and justice a: The war brought many women into shops and factories, often over the objections of men who saw them driving wage scales down.

They lived in slum tenements owned by the company, were paid in scrip, which they could use only at company stores, and were evicted if their work was unsatisfactory.

For most people today, of course, the answer to this is obvious: Their answer differs from Aristotle's, but it is worth pointing out the persistence of the problem and the difficulty of solving it. It would be wrong for the other people in the city to claim the right to rule over them or share rule with them, just as it would be wrong for people to claim the right to share power with Zeus.

Aristotle goes on to explain how the constitutions may be preserved. In this case, however, the husband does not alternate rule with the wife but instead always rules. This was the political problem that was of most concern to the authors of the United States Constitution: A negative attitude to oligarchy became traditional.

In Greece in Aristotle's time the important political entities were cities, which controlled surrounding territories that were farmed.


When a native Mississippian and an ex-confederate officer, in addressing a convention, refers to a colored delegate who has preceded him as "the gentleman from Georgia". After a week, however, with the threat of bringing in militia, the children returned to work, and their leaders were fired.

Also, there was the new urban white-collar worker, born in the rising commerce of the time, described by Thomas Cochran and William Miller The Age of Enterprise: Living under the shade of Bunker Hill monument, demanding in the name of humanity, our right, and withholding those rights from others because their skin is black!.

In his essay, Transformation of Democracy to Oligarchy. Former President Jimmy Carter believes that the American democracy has been transformed to an oligarchy.

Wikipedia and the Oligarchy of Ignorance

The iron law of oligarchy is a political theory, first developed by the German sociologist Robert Michels in his book, Political Parties. It asserts that rule by an elite, or oligarchy, is inevitable as an "iron law" within any democratic organization as part of the "tactical and technical necessities" of organization.

Michels's theory states that all complex organizations, regardless of. A sheriff in the Hudson River Valley near Albany, New York, about to go into the hills in the fall of to collect back rents from tenants on the enormous Rensselaer estate, was handed a letter.

The Second Gilded Age: Has America Become an Oligarchy?

Democracy Or Oligarchy? A Comparative Essay - During the Classical Age of Greece, two powerful city-states emerged, each governed by a different system. This essay will explain the iron law of oligarchy and see if trade union officials in Zambia. exhibit oligarchic tendencies. It will start by defining some terms and then give a detailed3/5(2).

Timothy Snyder is a Yale historian whose scholarly reputation rests on his wide-ranging histories of Central and Eastern Europe. Trained at Oxford, Snyder demonstrated a capacity for research in.

Iron law of oligarchy Essay on oligarchy
Rated 3/5 based on 10 review
Iron law of oligarchy - Wikipedia